Chicago 17 vs 18 — The Definitive Comparison

The Chicago Manual of Style 18th edition (released September 2024) is the most comprehensive revision since the 17th edition arrived in 2017. If you’ve been writing papers using Chicago 17 rules and haven’t checked what’s changed, some of your citations and even your sentence-level grammar may now be outdated.

Here’s what actually changed—organised by category—along with concrete examples and a decision table so you know exactly which edition to use.


What Changed: Citation Formatting

Three major changes affect how you format bibliographic entries. If you’ve ever used a citation manager, some of these will look familiar—but a few are genuinely new.

Publisher City Removal

Chicago 17: Included the city of publication in every book citation.

Chicago 18: Drops the publisher city entirely. The rationale is simple: in the digital age, where the publisher is located no longer adds meaningful information for locating the source.

Format Chicago 17 Chicago 18
Book (NB system) Beard, Mary. SPQR: A History of Ancient Rome. New York: Liveright, 2015. Beard, Mary. SPQR: A History of Ancient Rome. Liveright, 2015.
Book (Author-Date) Beard, Mary. 2015. SPQR: A History of Ancient Rome. New York: Liveright. Beard, Mary. 2015. SPQR: A History of Ancient Rome. Liveright.

Note: The city is still included for unpublished dissertations and certain legal documents, but for standard published books, it’s gone.

Author Limits Changed

Chicago 17: Listed up to 10 authors in bibliographies. Used “et al.” in footnotes after the first author for works with many authors.

Chicago 18: Extends the limit to 13 authors in bibliographies. The “et al.” rule for notes remains unchanged.

This matters for fields like sociology or interdisciplinary studies, where edited volumes and multi-author research collections are common. If you previously truncated a 10-author list with “et al.” in the bibliography, the 18th edition expects you to list all 13.

The 3-Em Dash Is Officially Retired

Chicago 17: When the author of a bibliography entry was the same as the previous entry, a 3-em dash was used as a shorthand to avoid repeating the author’s name.

Chicago 18: The 3-em dash is no longer used. Instead, the author’s full name is repeated in every entry.

This is one of the more disruptive changes for students with long bibliographies. Previously, you could write:

Adams, Richard. *Heart of a Dog*. 1977.
[---]
*The Garden of Paradise*. 1980.

Now you must write:

Adams, Richard. *Heart of a Dog*. 1977.
Adams, Richard. *The Garden of Paradise*. 1980.

It’s longer, but it eliminates ambiguity—especially when a bibliography mixes authors and the dash might be misread.

Shortened Citations Get a New Structure

Chicago 18 introduces three officially defined forms for shortened citations, replacing the previously flexible approach:

  1. Author-Title: The author’s name followed by a shortened version of the title.
  2. Author-Only: Just the author’s name (when the title is obvious from context).
  3. Title-Only: Just the title (when the author is obvious).

The old “ibid.” form is replaced by these three structured options, making shortened citations more predictable.


Grammar and Style Changes

These changes affect your actual writing, not just the formatting. They’re the kind of rules you’ll encounter on a professor’s grading rubric.

Singular “They” Gets Full Endorsement

Chicago 17: Acknowledged singular “they” as increasingly common but retained a formal tone that subtly discouraged it in academic prose.

Chicago 18: Explicitly endorses singular “they” as grammatically correct and appropriate in formal writing. The manual cites its own precedent from the 14th edition (1993), which already recognised the usage by citing examples in Austen and Shakespeare. Mary Laur, UChicago Press executive editor who led the revision effort, described this endorsement as “the single most anticipated change of the 18th edition.”

Why this matters: You’ve been using singular “they” for years in your writing. Chicago 18 finally says so out loud. This change alone resolves debates that have dragged across decades of usage guides.

Quick fact: Singular “they” wasn’t invented by modern usage guides. It appears in Shakespeare, Austen, and dozens of academic journals. The 18th edition’s move is less about “newness” and more about catching up to what professional writing has already accepted.

Colon Capitalization Revised

Chicago 17: Capitalised the word immediately following a colon only when it introduced a formal quotation or a heading.

Chicago 18: Capitalises both sides of a colon when both sides contain complete sentences. If the second clause is not a complete sentence, the word after the colon is lowercased (unless it’s a proper noun).

Title Case for Section Headings

The 18th edition clarifies that section headings in academic papers should follow headline-style capitalization (major words capitalised, minor words lowercased), not sentence case. This is particularly relevant for thesis chapters and journal article section headings.


Inclusive Language Updates

Chicago 18 makes several changes designed to reflect how identity terms are used in contemporary academic writing.

Identity Term Capitalization

Chicago 17: Capitalised terms for racial, ethnic, and cultural identity when referring to individuals or communities. Lowercased when used as adjectives.

Chicago 18: Strengthens the capitalisation rule. The manual now explicitly requires capitalising:

  • Black (referring to people or communities)
  • Indigenous (referring to specific Indigenous peoples or communities)
  • Native (referring to Native peoples or communities)

The guidance notes that these terms should be lowercased when used as general descriptors (e.g., “the Indigenous population of the region”), but capitalised when they refer to specific peoples or communities. This is a significant change for students writing in anthropology, sociology, or history.

Acknowledgments Moved to Back Matter

Chicago 17: Preferred placing acknowledgments in the front matter (before the main text).

Chicago 18: Prefers placing acknowledgments in the back matter (after the main text, before the bibliography). The rationale is that acknowledgments contain personal commentary that can distract readers before they engage with the content.

Exception: The Chicago Manual of Style itself continues to place acknowledgments in front matter, since it’s the book about itself.

Ibis. Is Retired

Chicago 17: Allowed “ibid.” (short for ibidem, meaning “in the same place”) for consecutive citations of the exact same source and page.

Chicago 18: Retires “ibid.” entirely. The manual replaces it with the three shortened citation forms described above.

The editorial rationale is straightforward: “ibid.” forces the reader to count back through footnotes to verify the source. The new system is more transparent—readers don’t need to flip through pages to confirm an author’s identity.


Brand-New: AI Citation Guidance (Section 14.112)

Chicago 18 introduces Section 14.112, which is entirely new and not covered in Chicago 17 at all. This is probably the single most relevant change for current students.

How to Cite AI Tools

Chicago 18 treats AI chatbots as personal communication, similar to informal conversations or interviews. The guidance recommends:

Footnote format:

1. User Name, personal communication (ChatGPT conversation), Month Day, Year.

Bibliography format:

Do not include AI-generated content in bibliographies. Only cite in footnotes or endnotes.

In-text citation:

(Personal communication, Month Day, Year)

Copyright and AI Disclosure

The 18th edition also introduces rules about disclosing AI use in published work. While this guidance is primarily aimed at professional authors and journal contributors, students should be aware of emerging expectations around transparency about AI assistance in academic work.


The Turabian Edition Mismatch (A Student Trap)

Here’s the single most common formatting mistake reported by students this year:

Thousands of students are using Turabian 9th edition rules when their professor expects Chicago 18 formatting.

Turabian’s A Manual for Writers of Papers, Theses, and Dissertations (9th edition, 2021) follows Chicago 17 rules. The upcoming Turabian 10th edition (anticipated October 2026) will align with Chicago 18.

Edition Follows Status
Turabian 9th Chicago 17 Current
Turabian 10th Chicago 18 Pending (Oct 2026)

The trap: You buy Turabian 9th, format your paper using its examples, submit it, and the professor marks down your bibliography because publisher cities aren’t omitted or “ibid.” isn’t retired. Your formatting isn’t wrong for Turabian 9th—it’s wrong for Chicago 18.

The fix: Ask your professor. Or check whether Turabian 10th has been adopted by your department. Until it’s released, treat Turabian 9th as a reference to Chicago 17, and verify against the official Chicago 18 guidelines if your professor specifies Chicago 18.


Which Edition Should You Use?

If you’re unsure which edition your professor or journal requires, use this decision table:

Situation Use Why
Your professor explicitly says “Chicago 18” or “18th edition” Chicago 18 The edition they requested
Your professor says “Chicago style” without specifying Chicago 18 It’s the current default (2024) unless stated otherwise
You’re using Turabian 9th and your professor hasn’t updated requirements Chicago 17 Turabian 9th follows Chicago 17
You’re using Turabian 10th or later Chicago 18 Turabian 10th follows Chicago 18
Submitting to an academic journal Check the journal’s author guidelines Journals may still require Chicago 17
Thesis or dissertation Check your department’s style guide Graduate programs often specify

Rule of thumb: Unless your professor explicitly says Chicago 17, assume they want Chicago 18. The 18th edition has been current for over two years now, and the default assumption in academic circles is Chicago 18.


Other Changes Worth Knowing

Emoji and Punctuation

Chicago 18 adds guidance for digital writing: punctuation now follows emojis in the same way it follows regular words. A sentence ending with an emoji gets its period after the emoji, not before. This may seem trivial, but it’s the kind of detail professors flag during grading.

Copyright Disclosure

New rules govern how to handle copyright information for images, illustrations, and reproduced materials. Students working on papers that include copyrighted content now need to follow stricter attribution and permission guidelines.

Digital Terms

The manual updates several digital-era terms:

  • Ebook is now lowercased (previously “e-book”)
  • Esports is lowercased
  • Text message in fiction dialogue is formatted with quotation marks and punctuation

The Comparison Table — Chicago 17 vs 18 Quick Reference

Category Change Chicago 17 Chicago 18
Citation Publisher city Included (e.g., “New York: Liveright”) Removed (e.g., “Liveright”)
Citation Author limits in bibliography Up to 10 authors Up to 13 authors
Citation 3-em dash Used for repeated-author entries Retired (repeat the name)
Citation Shortened citation format Flexible; “ibid.” for consecutive same-source citations Three defined forms: author-title, author-only, title-only
Citation “Ibid.” Allowed for consecutive citations of same source and page Retired entirely
Grammar Singular “they” Acknowledged; discouraged implicitly Explicitly endorsed
Grammar Colon capitalization Capitalized only before formal quotes/headings Capitalized both sides when both are complete sentences
Grammar Title case for headings Ambiguous; often sentence case Headline-style capitalization
Inclusive Language Identity terms (Black, Indigenous, Native) Capitalized as nouns, lowercased as adjectives Stronger capitalization guidance for communities and peoples
Structure Acknowledgments placement Front matter Back matter (except for CMOS itself)
New AI citation (Section 14.112) No guidance Treat AI as personal communication; cite in footnotes only
New Copyright disclosure Standard guidelines Stricter attribution and permission rules

Why Chicago 18 Matters Right Now

Here’s the reality: most professors and academic journals have already transitioned to Chicago 18. The 18th edition isn’t a future standard—it’s the current standard for academic publishing in the humanities and social sciences.

If you’re writing a paper, thesis, or dissertation that requires Chicago style, you’re writing in Chicago 18 unless your instructor explicitly specifies otherwise. That means:

  1. Drop publisher cities from your book citations.
  2. Replace “ibid.” with the new shortened citation forms.
  3. List up to 13 authors instead of 10.
  4. Use singular “they” confidently—it’s officially endorsed now.
  5. Cite AI tools according to Section 14.112 if your professor expects it.

The first draft is not where the grade is won. The formatting is. A professor who catches outdated Chicago 17 formatting can deduct five to ten points before looking at your actual argument. Make sure you’re using the right edition.


Frequently Asked Questions

What if I’m writing in Chicago Author-Date instead of Notes-Bibliography?

The changes apply to both systems. You’ll drop the publisher city, list up to 13 authors, and follow the inclusive language capitalization rules. The only difference is that the shortened citation forms primarily affect the Notes-Bibliography system.

Do I need to update existing citations I’ve already written?

If you’re drafting a new paper or thesis, use Chicago 18 from the start. If you’re revising an old paper formatted in Chicago 17, you should update the bibliographic entries and formatting rules. However, if your professor hasn’t specified a version, the change is less consequential than it used to be—professors are generally more forgiving about edition mismatches than they are about missing citations or formatting inconsistencies.

What about citing AI-generated sources?

Section 14.112 applies to Chicago 18. If your professor expects Chicago 18 and you cite an AI tool, use the personal communication format in footnotes and do not include AI tools in your bibliography. This is a brand-new rule—Chicago 17 has no equivalent guidance.

Is the singular “they” change retroactive?

Yes. If you previously used singular “they” and a professor marked it down, that feedback is now outdated. Chicago 18 explicitly endorses singular “they” in formal academic writing. You’re not rewriting an essay—you’re correcting a rule that didn’t exist until the 18th edition.


Next Steps

If you’re working with Chicago style:

  1. Check your professor’s syllabus or assignment guidelines to confirm which edition they require.
  2. Verify your citation manager’s style (Zotero, Mendeley, or EndNote) is set to Chicago 18 if that’s what your instructor expects.
  3. Use a citation verification resource like the official CMOS website or Purdue OWL Chicago 18 updates to double-check entries.
  4. If you’re using Turabian, confirm whether your department has adopted Turabian 9th or the upcoming 10th.

Related guides:

I’m new here 15% OFF